misc.fitness.weights

on FitnessDiscussions.com

  Home  |  Books  |  Fitness.Weights Newsgroup  |  Resources  |  Contact  | 
Sign in
username:

password:

Remember Me

Not a member?
Search misc.fitness.weights

Search Tips

misc.fitness.weights -> Obesity hard on the knees

There are 40 messages in this thread.
You are currently looking at messages 1 to 20.






Author: exzuberance
Date: 11:16 18-02-07


http://tinyurl.com/2wpa3x



Author: JMW
Date: 12:59 18-02-07

exzuberances@yahoo.com (exzuberance) wrote:

>http://tinyurl.com/2wpa3x

Not exactly a news flash. I've known many fat guys in their 40s who
required knee surgery, and it's been happening for decades.

Author: Shute
Date: 15:09 18-02-07

On Sun, 18 Feb 2007 12:59:44 -0500, JMW
<jmwilliams@enforcergraphics.f2s.com> wrote:

>exzuberances@yahoo.com (exzuberance) wrote:
>
>>http://tinyurl.com/2wpa3x
>
>Not exactly a news flash. I've known many fat guys in their 40s who
>required knee surgery, and it's been happening for decades.

It can get a lot worse. I watched a show about a 750 lbs man. The
day his legs went out from under him was a major turning point. Once
he was bedridden he ballooned up from the 500 lbs range to the 700 lbs
range. Once an obese person loses their mobility they are heading
into a new level of obesity. He ended up dying at 37 years old.

Author: jcderkoeing
Date: 18:22 18-02-07


"Shute" <Shute@nowhere.com> wrote in message
news:gacht2p35pidu78pebdn91e1ruj7117sc3@4ax.com...
>
> It can get a lot worse. Once an obese person loses their mobility they
> are heading into a new level of obesity.

Only if someone brings them food.



Author: Omelet
Date: 18:58 18-02-07

In article <cd5Ch.15560$O02.1822@newssvr11.news.prodigy.net>,
"jcderkoeing" <jcderkoenig@ibm.com> wrote:

> "Shute" <Shute@nowhere.com> wrote in message
> news:gacht2p35pidu78pebdn91e1ruj7117sc3@4ax.com...
> >
> > It can get a lot worse. Once an obese person loses their mobility they
> > are heading into a new level of obesity.
>
> Only if someone brings them food.

Agreed...
--
Peace, Om

Remove _ to validate e-mails.

"My mother never saw the irony in calling me a Son of a bitch" -- Jack
Nicholson

Author: Lucas Buck
Date: 19:41 18-02-07

On Sun, 18 Feb 2007 15:09:32 -0500, Shute <Shute@nowhere.com> wrote:

>On Sun, 18 Feb 2007 12:59:44 -0500, JMW
><jmwilliams@enforcergraphics.f2s.com> wrote:
>
>>exzuberances@yahoo.com (exzuberance) wrote:
>>
>>>http://tinyurl.com/2wpa3x
>>
>>Not exactly a news flash. I've known many fat guys in their 40s who
>>required knee surgery, and it's been happening for decades.
>
>It can get a lot worse. I watched a show about a 750 lbs man. The
>day his legs went out from under him was a major turning point. Once
>he was bedridden he ballooned up from the 500 lbs range to the 700 lbs
>range. Once an obese person loses their mobility they are heading
>into a new level of obesity. He ended up dying at 37 years old.

Yeah, funny how all that food magically transported itself to him.

I watched one of those on TLC or Discovery... a guy gets towed into the hospital
for evaluation for surgeries, but they can't fix his medical complications first.

His family snuck him in snacks.

Snacks.
While on his deathbed (and indeed, it proved to be) for obesity.


Author: David Cohen
Date: 20:35 18-02-07


"Lucas Buck" <sbcpark@earthlink.NOSPAM.net> wrote
> Shute <Shute@nowhere.com> wrote:
>> JMW<jmwilliams@enforcergraphics.f2s.com> wrote:
>>
>>>exzuberances@yahoo.com (exzuberance) wrote:
>>>
>>>>http://tinyurl.com/2wpa3x
>>>
>>>Not exactly a news flash. I've known many fat guys in their 40s who
>>>required knee surgery, and it's been happening for decades.
>>
>>It can get a lot worse. I watched a show about a 750 lbs man. The
>>day his legs went out from under him was a major turning point. Once
>>he was bedridden he ballooned up from the 500 lbs range to the 700 lbs
>>range. Once an obese person loses their mobility they are heading
>>into a new level of obesity. He ended up dying at 37 years old.
>
> Yeah, funny how all that food magically transported itself to him.
>
> I watched one of those on TLC or Discovery... a guy gets towed into the
> hospital
> for evaluation for surgeries, but they can't fix his medical complications
> first.
>
> His family snuck him in snacks.
>
> Snacks.

> While on his deathbed (and indeed, it proved to be) for obesity.

You're not being very sensitive to the gravitationally challenged.

Good thing you didn't crosspost it to the fat acceptance folks.

David



Author: 223rem
Date: 20:55 18-02-07

Shute wrote:
> On Sun, 18 Feb 2007 12:59:44 -0500, JMW
> <jmwilliams@enforcergraphics.f2s.com> wrote:
>
>> exzuberances@yahoo.com (exzuberance) wrote:
>>
>>> http://tinyurl.com/2wpa3x
>> Not exactly a news flash. I've known many fat guys in their 40s who
>> required knee surgery, and it's been happening for decades.
>
> It can get a lot worse. I watched a show about a 750 lbs man. The
> day his legs went out from under him was a major turning point. Once
> he was bedridden he ballooned up from the 500 lbs range to the 700 lbs
> range. Once an obese person loses their mobility they are heading
> into a new level of obesity. He ended up dying at 37 years old.

How could you watch something like that without throwing up? I'd send
these slugs to subsaharan Africa as food aid.

Author: Shute
Date: 21:32 18-02-07

On Sun, 18 Feb 2007 20:55:06 -0500, 223rem <223rem@gmail.com> wrote:

>Shute wrote:
>> On Sun, 18 Feb 2007 12:59:44 -0500, JMW
>> <jmwilliams@enforcergraphics.f2s.com> wrote:
>>
>>> exzuberances@yahoo.com (exzuberance) wrote:
>>>
>>>> http://tinyurl.com/2wpa3x
>>> Not exactly a news flash. I've known many fat guys in their 40s who
>>> required knee surgery, and it's been happening for decades.
>>
>> It can get a lot worse. I watched a show about a 750 lbs man. The
>> day his legs went out from under him was a major turning point. Once
>> he was bedridden he ballooned up from the 500 lbs range to the 700 lbs
>> range. Once an obese person loses their mobility they are heading
>> into a new level of obesity. He ended up dying at 37 years old.
>
>How could you watch something like that without throwing up? I'd send
>these slugs to subsaharan Africa as food aid.

They had another show on tonight about people consuming 13000 calories
a day. They laid out their daily intake of food on a table and showed
it to each of them. I did feel like throwing up looking at all that
food. One of them pulled the table in closer and started chowing
down.


Author: Lucas Buck
Date: 23:53 18-02-07

On Sun, 18 Feb 2007 21:32:44 -0500, Shute <Shute@nowhere.com> wrote:

>On Sun, 18 Feb 2007 20:55:06 -0500, 223rem <223rem@gmail.com> wrote:
>
>>Shute wrote:
>>> On Sun, 18 Feb 2007 12:59:44 -0500, JMW
>>> <jmwilliams@enforcergraphics.f2s.com> wrote:
>>>
>>>> exzuberances@yahoo.com (exzuberance) wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> http://tinyurl.com/2wpa3x
>>>> Not exactly a news flash. I've known many fat guys in their 40s who
>>>> required knee surgery, and it's been happening for decades.
>>>
>>> It can get a lot worse. I watched a show about a 750 lbs man. The
>>> day his legs went out from under him was a major turning point. Once
>>> he was bedridden he ballooned up from the 500 lbs range to the 700 lbs
>>> range. Once an obese person loses their mobility they are heading
>>> into a new level of obesity. He ended up dying at 37 years old.
>>
>>How could you watch something like that without throwing up? I'd send
>>these slugs to subsaharan Africa as food aid.
>
>They had another show on tonight about people consuming 13000 calories
>a day. They laid out their daily intake of food on a table and showed
>it to each of them. I did feel like throwing up looking at all that
>food. One of them pulled the table in closer and started chowing
>down.

WORSE. It's *33,000** calories a day! (THIRTY-THREE THOUSAND)

http://tlc.discovery.com/tvlistings/episode.jsp?episode=2&cpi=55746&gid=0&ch
annel=TLC


Author: Will Brink
Date: 09:50 19-02-07

In article <rq4ht2l2f3p7cuffl0220up6ssba4s02ci@4ax.com>, JMW
<jmwilliams@enforcergraphics.f2s.com> wrote:

> exzuberances@yahoo.com (exzuberance) wrote:
>
> >http://tinyurl.com/2wpa3x
>
> Not exactly a news flash. I've known many fat guys in their 40s who
> required knee surgery, and it's been happening for decades.

Hip replacement is also a common one. Back problems another. Many people
experience reduction, or a total end, to their back problems when they
lose weight. If I were to carry around a 30 -50lb pack on my back all day,
my knees and back would hurt too...

Author: Charles
Date: 10:37 19-02-07

On Mon, 19 Feb 2007 09:50:12 -0500, willbrink@comcast.net (Will Brink)
wrote:

>In article <rq4ht2l2f3p7cuffl0220up6ssba4s02ci@4ax.com>, JMW
><jmwilliams@enforcergraphics.f2s.com> wrote:
>
>> exzuberances@yahoo.com (exzuberance) wrote:
>>
>> >http://tinyurl.com/2wpa3x
>>
>> Not exactly a news flash. I've known many fat guys in their 40s who
>> required knee surgery, and it's been happening for decades.
>
>Hip replacement is also a common one. Back problems another. Many people
>experience reduction, or a total end, to their back problems when they
>lose weight. If I were to carry around a 30 -50lb pack on my back all day,
>my knees and back would hurt too...

It's your arse that takes all your knocks Will, given that you suffer
with Ducks' Disease.

This is a problem that afflicts most very short people, whereby every
time they step off the kerb, their arse hits the pavement! ;o)

Author: ZigZag
Date: 10:40 19-02-07

On Feb 19, 8:50 am, willbr...@comcast.net (Will Brink) wrote:
> In article <rq4ht2l2f3p7cuffl0220up6ssba4s0...@4ax.com>, JMW
>
> <jmwilli...@enforcergraphics.f2s.com> wrote:
> > exzuberan...@yahoo.com (exzuberance) wrote:
>
> > >http://tinyurl.com/2wpa3x
>
> > Not exactly a news flash. I've known many fat guys in their 40s who
> > required knee surgery, and it's been happening for decades.
>
> Hip replacement is also a common one. Back problems another. Many people
> experience reduction, or a total end, to their back problems when they
> lose weight. If I were to carry around a 30 -50lb pack on my back all day,
> my knees and back would hurt too...

Your knees can't tell the difference between muscle and fat. If you
weigh 250 lbs, are muscular and perform cardio exercises that have
impact, you are as likely a candidate for knee replacement as the 300
lb fat person. The shock loading of knees and hips can be worse than
static loading.

Best to keep weight to under 200 lbs, be it shape, but avoid high
impact aerobic exercise.



Author: Manco
Date: 10:59 19-02-07

ZigZag wrote:
> Best to keep weight to under 200 lbs, be it shape, but avoid high
> impact aerobic exercise.

Somehow that's not an issue for FA posters!



Author: george
Date: 11:12 19-02-07

ZigZag wrote:

> Your knees can't tell the difference between muscle and fat. If you
> weigh 250 lbs, are muscular and perform cardio exercises that have
> impact, you are as likely a candidate for knee replacement as the 300
> lb fat person. The shock loading of knees and hips can be worse than
> static loading.

That's pretty dumb.

Author: Manco
Date: 14:00 19-02-07

george wrote:
> ZigZag wrote:
>
>> Your knees can't tell the difference between muscle and fat. If you
>> weigh 250 lbs, are muscular and perform cardio exercises that have
>> impact, you are as likely a candidate for knee replacement as the 300
>> lb fat person. The shock loading of knees and hips can be worse
>> than static loading.
>
> That's pretty dumb.

It is, because muscle around the knee aka quads protect the kneecap and
ligaments. The muscle itself is not a problem for the joints, unless the
mass becomes really huge.



Author: Will Brink
Date: 17:52 19-02-07

In article <1171899633.704411.132420@l53g2000cwa.googlegroups.com>,
"ZigZag" <zieglersr@yahoo.com> wrote:

> On Feb 19, 8:50 am, willbr...@comcast.net (Will Brink) wrote:
> > In article <rq4ht2l2f3p7cuffl0220up6ssba4s0...@4ax.com>, JMW
> >
> > <jmwilli...@enforcergraphics.f2s.com> wrote:
> > > exzuberan...@yahoo.com (exzuberance) wrote:
> >
> > > >http://tinyurl.com/2wpa3x
> >
> > > Not exactly a news flash. I've known many fat guys in their 40s who
> > > required knee surgery, and it's been happening for decades.
> >
> > Hip replacement is also a common one. Back problems another. Many people
> > experience reduction, or a total end, to their back problems when they
> > lose weight. If I were to carry around a 30 -50lb pack on my back all day,
> > my knees and back would hurt too...
>
> Your knees can't tell the difference between muscle and fat.

Cite.

> If you
> weigh 250 lbs, are muscular and perform cardio exercises that have
> impact, you are as likely a candidate for knee replacement as the 300
> lb fat person.

Cite

> The shock loading of knees and hips can be worse than
> static loading.

Agreed.

>
> Best to keep weight to under 200 lbs, be it shape, but avoid high
> impact aerobic exercise.

It's not that simple.

--
Will @ www.BrinkZone.com

"It twas ever thus " - Mr Natural

Author: Will Brink
Date: 17:56 19-02-07

In article <xtmCh.3129$2w.1064@trndny09>, "Manco"
<manco_dollars@net2blah.com> wrote:

> george wrote:
> > ZigZag wrote:
> >
> >> Your knees can't tell the difference between muscle and fat. If you
> >> weigh 250 lbs, are muscular and perform cardio exercises that have
> >> impact, you are as likely a candidate for knee replacement as the 300
> >> lb fat person. The shock loading of knees and hips can be worse
> >> than static loading.
> >
> > That's pretty dumb.
>
> It is, because muscle around the knee aka quads protect the kneecap and
> ligaments. The muscle itself is not a problem for the joints, unless the
> mass becomes really huge.

Says who and based on what? Huge bodybuilders, of which I know many, don't
appear to suffer knee injuries more often then anyo ther athlete. Joint
problems are not uncommon per se, but are probably due to other factors
like huge loads, muscle imbalances, etc. As fas as I know, big foot ball
players don't suffer more joint problems then smaller players, and skinny
runners often have plenty of joint issues. I don't believe the issue has
been studied directly, so it's conjecture.

--
Will @ www.BrinkZone.com

"It twas ever thus " - Mr Natural

Author: throatslasher
Date: 20:58 19-02-07

On Feb 19, 2:52 pm, willbr...@comcast.net (Will Brink) wrote:
> "ZigZag" <ziegle...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> > Your knees can't tell the difference between muscle and fat.
>
> Cite.

You're kidding, right?


Author: 223rem
Date: 20:58 19-02-07

ZigZag wrote:

> Your knees can't tell the difference between muscle and fat. If you
> weigh 250 lbs, are muscular and perform cardio exercises that have
> impact, you are as likely a candidate for knee replacement as the 300
> lb fat person.

That's really stupid. A big muscular guy got that way by lifting heavy
weights. Lifting heavy does more than enlarge your muscles, it
strengthens your bones, tendons, and ligaments.

A 300 lb tub of lard on the other hand spends most of his time laying
down on a couch, his bones are demineralized and his tendons and
ligaments weak.

There is no comparison.

1 2


      Contact  |  Fitness


misc.fitness.weights by Keywords
Alcohol
Arnold
Bodybuilding
Bodyfat
Bowflex
Creatine
Deadlift
Ephedra
HST
Hypertrophy
Kettlebell
Powerlifting
Protein
Pullups
Pushups
Resistance
Sheiko
Squat
Steroids
Supplements
Testosterone
Video
Vitamin

misc.fitness.weights By Author